Please correct me if I am wrong but you never mention the use of a
probability calculator (e.g., Monte Carlo Probability Calculator) as a
way to get help in choosing the strike prices and hence, a position with
a good risk/reward profile for a spread or IC.
Is it useless or is delta good enough for checking the probability or
is there some other reason?
You are right. I have never discussed using a probability calculator, and it's time to correct that oversight.
Those calculators are far from useless.
In addition to the calculator mentioned above, Peter Hoadley offers another. Unless you buy his software package, use of the free online version is limited.
What does a probability calculator do?
Needless to say it calculates the probability for the occurrence of specific events.
discussion is about the probability calculator and the useful
information it can provide. Thus, I'm going to be talking about
expiration and the chances that an option will finish (expiration closing price) ITM or OTM.
If you are like me, and prefer not to own positions through expiration, you can
change the number of trading days to agree with how long you intend to
own the position.
important point: in this discussion ITM simply means in the money.
Clearly it makes a difference whether the option is 10 cents or 10
dollars ITM. Thus, just because the option is ITM at expiration, it
does not mean that you have a loss. It depends how far ITM. This idea is
not part of today's post.
Probability of option expiring worthless
As a premium seller, it's important to know the chances that the option you sold will be in the money when expiration arrives. You must decide whether the potential reward justifies the risk – and the probabilities can be considered when making that decision.
Option buyers also benefit by having a good idea of how often their option will finish in the money. As with premium sellers, when the option is held through expiration day, all time premium is lost and the profitability of the trade is determined by how far ITM the option moves.
What you already know
Option traders already know the chances an option will finish ITM, because the option delta gives a good approximation of that probability.
But that's not enough information to evaluate the risk of owning a specific position. More information would be useful – unless you are someone who opens the trade, closes his/her eyes and opens them on expiration Friday. That's too risky for me, but some iron condor traders do just that. If that describes your modus operandi, then the probability of expiring worthless is all you have to consider when looking at probabilities.
For everyone else, there is more to consider. These probability calculators provide very useful information, including the probability that one or both options will be in the money – at some time – before the options expire.
Probability of underlying reaching a specific price
You can calculate the probability that the underlying stock or index will move far enough before expiration arrives, so that it touches a specific price. For most traders, the strike price is the number used. But there are alternatives. For example, a trader who depends on technical analysis may want to determine the probability of hitting a resistance or support price.
Let's look at an example:
RUT is 514.92
RVX is 29.34, and we'll use that as the volatility
As of this morning, Monday 10/12/2009, November expiration is 6 weeks or 39 days (30 trading days) in the future. The Hoadley calculator uses calendar days and the Monte Carlo calculator uses trading days. Assume we trade the following iron condor, collecting a premium of $1.60: NOTE: This is an example, not a recommendation, so please don't ask why I chose this IC. [It's based on the premium available, and yes, I know it's far from delta neutral]
252 trading days in one year
Sell RUT Nov 530/540 put spread
Sell RUT Nov 670/680 call spread
Delta of 540 put: 11.6; delta of 670 call: 16.8 Total delta 28.4
a) Using the Monte Carlo Probability Calculator (MCPC), 10,000 trials is maximum allowed
Results: 10,000 is not that many trials. If you run this several times, you will get different results each time.
1) Delta says 28.4% chance that one option will close ITM and MCPC says 29.48
2) The calls will move ITM one third of the time; the puts move ITM one time in six. There is a greater than 50% chance that one of the options will move ITM. If you are someone who manages risk carefully, that suggests you will be making an adjustment most of the time. And that's even more true if you adjust in stages and don't wait until one of the options has moved into the money
If the idea of knowing you will be forced to make an adjustment so often bothers you, then you have little choice but to sell call and put spreads that are farther OTM. Or, you can trade a stock or index that is less volatile. Either way, that means smaller premiums.
3) The probability that each of the short options will be in the money is near zero. But, if you find yourself making an adjustment on one half of the position, I believe it pays to exit the winning side of the iron condor when it reaches a satisfactory low price.
b) Using the Hoadley calculator
1) Probability that one will end ITM: 27.0%. This is lower than the other calculator or delta predicted
2) This calculator shows a higher probability of either option moving into the money: 36 vs. 33% for the calls and 18.4 vs. 17.4% for the puts
3) Low probability of both being ITM at one time or another, but again, the probability is a bit higher using this calculator
Probability calculators provide information "that can be of significant value when used in a conscientiously applied program of option trading and regular risk management."
Does anyone recognize the origin of most of the words in the final paragraph? It's not fair to use any search engine.